Career Comparisons

Electrician vs Plumber: Which Trade Fits You Better?

On pay, electricians and plumbers are almost a dead heat: the national median in May 2025 was $63,190 for electricians and $63,800 for plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Both trades train through a paid apprenticeship of four or five years. So the better choice comes down to things the salary tables hide: how many openings there are near you, what kind of physical work you can live with for 30 years, and whether you mind being the person who gets called at 2 a.m. when a pipe bursts.

Below you will find the two trades side by side, the differences in daily work and risk, how licensing works, and a short test to help you pick.

The numbers side by side

Pay figures come from the BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics survey for May 2025. Job counts, growth and openings come from the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook projections for 2025 to 2035.

MeasureElectriciansPlumbers, pipefitters, steamfitters
Median annual pay$63,190$63,800
Median hourly pay$30.38$30.67
Bottom 10% earn under$42,640$44,150
Top 10% earn over$108,510$108,420
Jobs in 2025821,000510,600
Projected growth, 2025 to 20359%7%
Openings per year (average)About 72,700About 42,000

Two things stand out. First, the pay range is nearly identical at every point, so neither trade is a shortcut to more money. Second, the electrical trade is bigger and opens up more positions each year, roughly 30,000 more. If you live somewhere with few contractors, that larger pool can make the first apprenticeship place easier to find. Check your own area, though: the national figures say nothing about your county. The electricians career profile and the plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters profile list the day-to-day tasks and skills for each.

How the apprenticeship works in each trade

The structure is the same on paper. BLS describes a 4 or 5 year apprenticeship for both, combining classroom instruction with roughly 2,000 paid working hours a year on site. Entry usually needs a high school diploma or equivalent.

What differs is the content. Electrical apprentices spend a lot of classroom time on electrical theory, code and reading blueprints, and the job site work is about wiring, panels, circuits and testing. Plumbing apprentices learn water supply, drainage and venting, fixtures, and in many programs gas piping, and the site work is cutting, joining and routing pipe.

Quick check: which classroom would you rather sit in?

  • If calculating loads and following a code book page by page sounds satisfying, the electrical side will suit you.
  • If you think in terms of flow, pressure and how water or gas moves through a building, plumbing will feel more natural.
  • If neither appeals, look at HVAC, which mixes both. Our guide to whether HVAC is a good career change covers that route.

Licensing: who needs a test, and when

Both trades are licensed in most of the US, but the rules sit with states and sometimes cities, so the exact path depends on where you work.

  • Electricians: BLS says most states require electricians to pass a test and hold a license, with requirements varying by state.
  • Plumbers: most states and some localities require a license, typically after 2 to 5 years of experience plus an exam. Some states also license pipefitters and steamfitters, and some require a separate license for gas line work.

The practical point: before you sign an apprenticeship agreement, check that its hours count toward the license in the state where you plan to work. Moving states later can mean extra exams, and a gas endorsement can be a separate step on top of a plumbing license.

Daily work and the physical toll

Both are physical jobs, but they wear on you differently. According to BLS, common injuries for electricians include electrical shocks, falls and burns. For plumbers, the common ones are cuts from sharp tools, burns from hot pipes and soldering equipment, and falls from ladders.

FactorElectricianPlumber
Typical spacesAttics, crawl spaces, ceilings, panelsUnder sinks, crawl spaces, trenches, basements
Main hazardShock and arc burnsCuts, hot surfaces, sewage exposure
Schedule patternFull time; overtime commonFull time; on call for emergencies

The schedule row matters more than people expect. BLS notes that plumbers are often on call, so evening and weekend work is common. Electricians also work evenings and weekends at times, and overtime is common, but emergency call-outs are a bigger part of residential plumbing. If you have young children or a second job, ask any employer how the on-call rota works before you accept.

O*NET's work context ratings point to another difference. On a 0 to 100 scale, where 100 means every day, electricians rate 57 for dealing with unpleasant or angry people and plumbers rate 42. Both rate above 80 for working to strict deadlines. Neither trade is calm, but plumbers report a little less friction with the public.

Where each trade can take you after the license

The top 10% in both trades earn more than $108,000, and that money usually comes from one of three moves:

  1. Specialising. Electricians can move into industrial controls, solar or low-voltage systems. Plumbers and pipefitters can move into commercial, industrial or steam systems, or gas line work where a state issues a separate license.
  2. Running jobs. Foreman and estimator roles pay for judgment rather than labour, which matters as your knees age.
  3. Owning the business. A contractor's license and your own customers raise the ceiling, along with the risk.

Customers notice the money side of this. A whole-house repipe, for example, is one of the larger plumbing jobs a homeowner pays for, and this breakdown of what repiping costs and when old pipes need replacing shows the kind of project a licensed plumber can quote for once they work independently.

A three-question test before you apply

Answer these honestly. Two or more answers in one column point you to that trade.

QuestionLeans electricianLeans plumber
Which mistake would worry you more?A wrong connection you cannot seeA leak that floods a ceiling
Are you fine with dirty, wet work?Prefer to avoid itYes, it does not bother me
How do you feel about call-outs?Want predictable hoursFine with emergency work for extra pay

Still split? Spend a day with a working tradesperson in each. Most contractors will let a serious applicant shadow, and a single day in a crawl space tells you more than any table.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do electricians or plumbers make more money?

Nationally they are almost equal. BLS May 2025 data puts the median at $63,190 for electricians and $63,800 for plumbers, pipefitters and steamfitters, and the top 10% in both earn over $108,000. Local demand, union membership, specialty and whether you run your own business make far more difference than the choice of trade.

Which trade is easier to get into?

Both usually need a high school diploma and a place on an apprenticeship. The electrical trade has more jobs and about 72,700 openings a year against roughly 42,000 for plumbing, so there may be more apprenticeship places. Competition for union programs can be strong in either trade, so apply to several sponsors.

Is plumbing or electrical work more dangerous?

They carry different risks. Electricians face shocks, arc burns and falls. Plumbers face cuts, burns from hot pipes and soldering tools, falls from ladders and exposure to sewage. Both are safe careers when you follow procedures and wear protective equipment, and both apprenticeships teach safety from the first year.

Can I switch from one trade to the other later?

Yes, but your hours usually count only toward the license you trained for, so switching often means a new apprenticeship or a shorter credit-based route, depending on the state. General site skills, blueprint reading and customer handling carry over. If you are unsure, HVAC sits between the two and uses parts of each.

The quick verdict

Pick electrical if you want the larger job market and cleaner, more technical work. Pick plumbing if you are comfortable with messy jobs and want emergency work to boost your income. Then call two local apprenticeship sponsors this week and ask when their next intake opens, because the waitlist, not the trade, is often what decides your start date.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional career advice. Occupational data sourced from O*NET and the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.